nonprofit fundraising guide

Best Envelopes for Nonprofits & Fundraising

Appeals • Remittance Reply Envelopes • Colored Envelopes • Year-End Campaigns • Donor Response

In fundraising mail, the envelope does two jobs: it gets the appeal opened, and it makes giving easy. A donor can’t respond to a letter they never open, and many won’t respond if the reply step takes effort.

This guide covers the best envelope for each part of the package, remittance Business Reply and Courtesy Reply envelopes that put the donor form on the flap, colored envelopes that stand out in the mailbox, formats and materials, and simple tests that raise response.

Already know what you need? Go straight to the product.

Best Envelopes for Fundraising: Picks by Job

Job Best Envelope Why It Works Shop
Donor reply, postage paid #9 Remittance Business Reply Donor form on the flap; no stamp needed Shop Remit BRM
Donor reply, donor adds stamp #9 Remittance Courtesy Reply Donor form on the flap; lower cost Shop Remit CRM
Smaller reply packages #6 3/4 Remittance Business Reply Same flap form in a smaller size Shop #6 3/4
Standard appeal outer #10 regular, 24# white Familiar, cost-efficient; holds a #9 reply Shop #10
Appeals that stand out #10 Prism (pastel) or Starburst (bold) Color gets noticed in the mailbox Shop Colored
Year-end and major campaigns 6 x 9 booklet, white or color Larger format feels more important Shop 6 x 9
Grassroots or eco look #10 kraft regular Natural, personal feel Shop Kraft
Reply envelope that stands out #9 Color Business Reply Easy to find in the package Shop Color BRM
The winning package: A #10 appeal (white or color) with a #9 remittance reply envelope inside. The remittance flap replaces a separate reply card, so there’s one less piece to print and nothing for the donor to lose.

Remittance Reply Envelopes: The Donor Form Is the Flap

A remittance envelope has an oversized flap printed on the inside with your reply form: gift amounts, name and address, and a check box for monthly giving. The donor fills in the flap, adds a check, and seals it. The envelope and reply card become one piece. Ours come in Business Reply and Courtesy Reply versions.

Remittance Business Reply (BRM)

Postage-paid: the donor doesn’t need a stamp.

  • Highest response; removes the biggest barrier to giving
  • You pay return postage only on envelopes that come back
  • Needs a USPS BRM permit; we print the permit, FIM, and barcode
  • #9, #6 3/4, and #6 1/4; white or 8 colors

Remittance Courtesy Reply (CRM)

Pre-addressed: the donor adds a stamp.

  • No permit or return postage for you
  • Great for warm lists, renewals, and monthly donors
  • Same printed flap form as the BRM version
  • #9; white or 8 colors
Reply Envelope Size Postage Shop
Remittance Business Reply #9 You pay when returned Shop #9
Remittance Business Reply #6 3/4 You pay when returned Shop #6 3/4
Remittance Business Reply #6 1/4 You pay when returned Shop #6 1/4
Remittance Courtesy Reply #9 Donor adds a stamp Shop #9
Color Business Reply #9 You pay when returned Shop Color
Business Reply (no flap form) #9 You pay when returned Shop BRM
Courtesy Reply (no flap form) #9 Donor adds a stamp Shop CRM
Flap form tips: Use big boxes for name, address, and gift amount. Offer three or four suggested amounts. Keep one clear ask. A #9 fits inside a #10 outer. To set up permits and artwork, see the Business Reply Mail guide.

Colored Envelopes Raise Open Rates: Stand Out in the Mailbox

Most mail is white. A colored envelope stands out in the stack and gets picked up first, which is why colored outers often lift open rates for appeals. Colored paper stock also costs less than printing color across a white envelope, and a matching colored reply envelope is easy for donors to find.

Envelope Colors Best For Shop
#10 Prism regular 8 pastel colors Appeals with a softer, friendly look Shop Prism
#10 Starburst regular 9 bold colors Urgent and year-end appeals Shop Starburst
6 x 9 Prism booklet 8 pastel colors Premium campaigns and newsletters Shop 6 x 9 Prism
6 x 9 Starburst booklet 9 bold colors Special campaigns that need to pop Shop 6 x 9 Bold
#9 and #10 Color Business Reply 8 pastel and 9 bold Reply envelopes that stand out Shop Color BRM
Remittance BRM and CRM White and 8 colors Colored reply with the donor form Shop Remittance
Make color work: Pick a color that fits your brand, keep the design clean, and print your logo and return address clearly. Color gets attention; a recognizable name gets the envelope opened.

Fundraising Envelope Strategy: Trust First, Then Curiosity

Trust signals

Donors decide in seconds whether to open. Familiar and legitimate wins.

  • Organization name and return address, upper left
  • Small, consistent logo
  • Clean design with white space
  • Readable addressing; handwritten-style fonts can feel personal

Curiosity signals

A short teaser can lift opens for warm lists and well-known groups.

  • Keep it 6–10 words and specific
  • Avoid “FINAL NOTICE” or “ACT NOW”
  • Use “why it matters” language
  • Test teaser vs no teaser

Easy response

Make giving the simplest thing in the package.

  • Remittance reply with the form on the flap
  • Postage-paid BRM for broad and new-donor lists
  • One clear ask with suggested amounts
Fundraising rule: Start with trust, then add attention: color, a teaser, or a larger format. Change one thing at a time so you know what worked.

Formats & Materials: Match the Package to the Ask

Every size is on envelopes by size, with durable options on Tyvek® by size and kraft envelopes by size.

Format Best For Why It Works Shop
#10 regular Standard appeals and stewardship Familiar; holds a #9 reply envelope Shop #10
#10 colored Appeals that need to stand out Gets noticed and opened Shop Colored
#10 kraft Grassroots and eco-minded groups Natural, personal feel Shop Kraft
6 x 9 booklet Year-end, major campaigns Feels more important than a #10 Shop 6 x 9
9 x 12 booklet Annual reports, packets Mails pages flat Shop 9 x 12
#10 window Receipts, renewals, membership billing Fast addressing; can look like a bill Shop Window
Tyvek® Kits and heavy packets Tear- and water-resistant Shop Tyvek®
Closures: Gum seals suit inserting machines and bulk runs. Self-seal styles speed up hand mailing. Never overstuff; a bulging envelope looks sloppy and can open in the mail.
The whole direct mail package: Guide: Direct Mail Envelopes
↑ Back to top

Testing Framework: Improve Results Without Guesswork

Test Version A Version B What You Learn
Outer color White #10 Colored #10 How much color lifts opens
Reply method Courtesy reply Business Reply How much postage-paid lifts response
Reply device Separate reply card Remittance flap Whether one piece raises returns
Format #10 6 x 9 Whether a larger package lifts gifts
Material White paper Kraft Which look your donors trust
Teaser No teaser Short teaser Curiosity vs trust on your list
Testing tip: Keep the list, letter, and offer the same and change one envelope variable at a time. Make the winner your new baseline. For large mailings, see postal optimization for bulk mailers.

FAQ: Nonprofit & Fundraising Envelopes

Quick answers on remittance reply envelopes, Business Reply vs Courtesy Reply, colored envelopes, formats, and testing.

What is a remittance envelope?
A reply envelope with an oversized flap printed on the inside with your donor form. The donor fills in the flap, adds a check, and seals it. See remittance envelopes.
Why are remittance envelopes good for fundraising?
The envelope and reply card are one piece, so there’s less to print, less to insert, and nothing for the donor to lose. The form and the gift come back together.
Remittance Business Reply or Remittance Courtesy Reply?
Business Reply is postage-paid, so donors don’t need a stamp; it usually gets the most responses. Courtesy Reply costs less because the donor adds the stamp. See Business Reply vs Courtesy Reply.
Do I need a permit for Business Reply envelopes?
Yes, a USPS Business Reply Mail permit. We print the permit number, FIM, and barcode in the correct layout. See the Business Reply Mail guide.
What sizes do remittance reply envelopes come in?
Remittance Business Reply comes in #9, #6 3/4, and #6 1/4. Remittance Courtesy Reply comes in #9. All are 24#, 500 per carton.
What colors do remittance envelopes come in?
White plus Creme, Canary, Goldenrod, Pink, Green, Blue, Gray, and Ivory.
Do colored envelopes increase open rates?
They often do. Most mail is white, so a colored envelope stands out and gets picked up first. Pair color with a clear organization name and return address so it looks legitimate.
Which colored envelopes do you carry?
#10 Prism in 8 pastel colors, #10 Starburst in 9 bold colors, 6 x 9 Prism and Starburst booklets, and colored Business Reply envelopes in #9 and #10.
What envelope size is best for fundraising letters?
The #10 is most common: familiar, cost-efficient, and it holds a #9 reply envelope. Use 6 x 9 when the campaign should feel more important.
Should fundraising envelopes have a window?
Most appeals use Non-Window (Regular) envelopes, which look personal and give more design control. Windows suit receipts, renewals, and billing. See window vs non-window.
Is kraft paper a good choice for nonprofit mail?
Kraft works well for grassroots and eco-minded groups. It feels personal and stands out. Print with high contrast and keep the design simple.
Can you print our logo and reply form?
Yes. Outer and reply envelopes print in black, 1, 2, or 4 color, and remittance flaps print on the inside. See custom printing.

Ready to Order Your Envelopes?

Shop by size, or talk with an envelope specialist who will match the right size, material, and closure to your mailing.

Doug Nelson

About Doug Nelson

Linkedin Profile

Over 40 years of hands-on expertise in the envelope and printing industry. At Easy Envelopes, I partner with businesses to deliver everything from high-volume stock orders to custom-manufactured specialty solutions, including durable Tyvek envelopes. My core focus is taking the guesswork out of mailing logistics. I work closely with the US Postal Service to guarantee that every business reply mail envelope we print meets strict USPS specifications, protecting my clients from costly compliance errors and ensuring they qualify for the absolute lowest postage rates.

© 2026 Easy Envelopes. Buyers Guide Knowledge Base.