Appeals • Remittance Reply Envelopes • Colored Envelopes • Year-End Campaigns • Donor Response
In fundraising mail, the envelope does two jobs: it gets the appeal opened, and it makes giving easy. A donor can’t respond to a letter they never open, and many won’t respond if the reply step takes effort.
This guide covers the best envelope for each part of the package, remittance Business Reply and Courtesy Reply envelopes that put the donor form on the flap, colored envelopes that stand out in the mailbox, formats and materials, and simple tests that raise response.
Already know what you need? Go straight to the product.
| Job | Best Envelope | Why It Works | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|
| Donor reply, postage paid | #9 Remittance Business Reply | Donor form on the flap; no stamp needed | Shop Remit BRM |
| Donor reply, donor adds stamp | #9 Remittance Courtesy Reply | Donor form on the flap; lower cost | Shop Remit CRM |
| Smaller reply packages | #6 3/4 Remittance Business Reply | Same flap form in a smaller size | Shop #6 3/4 |
| Standard appeal outer | #10 regular, 24# white | Familiar, cost-efficient; holds a #9 reply | Shop #10 |
| Appeals that stand out | #10 Prism (pastel) or Starburst (bold) | Color gets noticed in the mailbox | Shop Colored |
| Year-end and major campaigns | 6 x 9 booklet, white or color | Larger format feels more important | Shop 6 x 9 |
| Grassroots or eco look | #10 kraft regular | Natural, personal feel | Shop Kraft |
| Reply envelope that stands out | #9 Color Business Reply | Easy to find in the package | Shop Color BRM |
A remittance envelope has an oversized flap printed on the inside with your reply form: gift amounts, name and address, and a check box for monthly giving. The donor fills in the flap, adds a check, and seals it. The envelope and reply card become one piece. Ours come in Business Reply and Courtesy Reply versions.
Postage-paid: the donor doesn’t need a stamp.
Pre-addressed: the donor adds a stamp.
| Reply Envelope | Size | Postage | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|
| Remittance Business Reply | #9 | You pay when returned | Shop #9 |
| Remittance Business Reply | #6 3/4 | You pay when returned | Shop #6 3/4 |
| Remittance Business Reply | #6 1/4 | You pay when returned | Shop #6 1/4 |
| Remittance Courtesy Reply | #9 | Donor adds a stamp | Shop #9 |
| Color Business Reply | #9 | You pay when returned | Shop Color |
| Business Reply (no flap form) | #9 | You pay when returned | Shop BRM |
| Courtesy Reply (no flap form) | #9 | Donor adds a stamp | Shop CRM |
Most mail is white. A colored envelope stands out in the stack and gets picked up first, which is why colored outers often lift open rates for appeals. Colored paper stock also costs less than printing color across a white envelope, and a matching colored reply envelope is easy for donors to find.
| Envelope | Colors | Best For | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|
| #10 Prism regular | 8 pastel colors | Appeals with a softer, friendly look | Shop Prism |
| #10 Starburst regular | 9 bold colors | Urgent and year-end appeals | Shop Starburst |
| 6 x 9 Prism booklet | 8 pastel colors | Premium campaigns and newsletters | Shop 6 x 9 Prism |
| 6 x 9 Starburst booklet | 9 bold colors | Special campaigns that need to pop | Shop 6 x 9 Bold |
| #9 and #10 Color Business Reply | 8 pastel and 9 bold | Reply envelopes that stand out | Shop Color BRM |
| Remittance BRM and CRM | White and 8 colors | Colored reply with the donor form | Shop Remittance |
Donors decide in seconds whether to open. Familiar and legitimate wins.
A short teaser can lift opens for warm lists and well-known groups.
Make giving the simplest thing in the package.
Every size is on envelopes by size, with durable options on Tyvek® by size and kraft envelopes by size.
| Format | Best For | Why It Works | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|
| #10 regular | Standard appeals and stewardship | Familiar; holds a #9 reply envelope | Shop #10 |
| #10 colored | Appeals that need to stand out | Gets noticed and opened | Shop Colored |
| #10 kraft | Grassroots and eco-minded groups | Natural, personal feel | Shop Kraft |
| 6 x 9 booklet | Year-end, major campaigns | Feels more important than a #10 | Shop 6 x 9 |
| 9 x 12 booklet | Annual reports, packets | Mails pages flat | Shop 9 x 12 |
| #10 window | Receipts, renewals, membership billing | Fast addressing; can look like a bill | Shop Window |
| Tyvek® | Kits and heavy packets | Tear- and water-resistant | Shop Tyvek® |
| Test | Version A | Version B | What You Learn |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outer color | White #10 | Colored #10 | How much color lifts opens |
| Reply method | Courtesy reply | Business Reply | How much postage-paid lifts response |
| Reply device | Separate reply card | Remittance flap | Whether one piece raises returns |
| Format | #10 | 6 x 9 | Whether a larger package lifts gifts |
| Material | White paper | Kraft | Which look your donors trust |
| Teaser | No teaser | Short teaser | Curiosity vs trust on your list |
Quick answers on remittance reply envelopes, Business Reply vs Courtesy Reply, colored envelopes, formats, and testing.
Shop by size, or talk with an envelope specialist who will match the right size, material, and closure to your mailing.
Over 40 years of hands-on expertise in the envelope and printing industry. At Easy Envelopes, I partner with businesses to deliver everything from high-volume stock orders to custom-manufactured specialty solutions, including durable Tyvek envelopes. My core focus is taking the guesswork out of mailing logistics. I work closely with the US Postal Service to guarantee that every business reply mail envelope we print meets strict USPS specifications, protecting my clients from costly compliance errors and ensuring they qualify for the absolute lowest postage rates.