Herculink vs Kraft Envelopes

Herculink® vs Kraft Envelopes: Which Is Right for Your Mailing?

Strength • Moisture • Styles • Printing • Cost

Herculink® puts a 26# reinforced fiber weave and a poly moisture barrier under a paper outer layer, so it resists tearing, bursting, and damp conditions while still looking like paper. Kraft paper is the classic brown or white envelope paper: strong for everyday mail, sold in far more styles, and lower in cost.

This guide compares the two side by side, lists every size and style we carry in each, and shows when the extra protection of Herculink® is worth it and when kraft is all you need.

Ready to order? Start here.

At a Glance: Herculink® vs Kraft Side by Side

Feature Herculink® Kraft Paper
Construction Paper outer layer, 26# reinforced fiber weave, poly moisture barrier Kraft paper, 24# to 40#
Tear and burst High; the weave stops tears and bursts Good for everyday handling
Moisture Moisture barrier; not waterproof Low; paper weakens when wet
Look Professional paper look, more rigid Natural brown or clean white
Styles Catalog, booklet, expansion 12 styles, from #10 to jumbo
Closures Zip Stick® (peel & seal) on every style Zip Stick®, gum, Peerless Tac, tin tie, and more
Printing Flats: black to 4 color; expansion: up to 2 Black, 1, 2, 3, or 4 color on most styles
Carton 500 flats; 250 or 100 expansion 500 on most styles
Cost Higher Lower
Recycling Ask your local program (has a poly layer) Recyclable paper
Quick pick: Choose Herculink® when contents are heavy, valuable, or may get damp on the way. Choose kraft for everyday documents, catalogs, and high-volume mail where cost matters. Need the most water resistance? Step up to Tyvek®.
Adding Tyvek® to the mix: Guide: Tyvek® vs Herculink®
↑ Back to top

Kraft Paper: Brown or White, Every Style

Brown or white

Choose the look.

  • Brown: natural look, hides scuffs
  • White: clean look, easy printing
  • Most flat styles come in both colors

Paper weights

24# to 40#.

  • 24# or 28#: commercial envelopes
  • 28#: catalog, booklet, and most flats
  • 40#: document envelopes and retention jackets

12 styles

Far more choice than Herculink®.

Picking a color? Brown kraft stands out next to white mail; white kraft reads cleaner for invoices and printing. See white vs brown kraft envelopes.

Sizes: What We Carry in Each

Size Kraft Paper Herculink® Shop
6 x 9 Catalog, booklet Catalog Shop 6 x 9
6 1/2 x 9 1/2 Catalog — Shop 6 1/2
7 1/2 x 10 1/2 Catalog Catalog Shop 7 1/2
9 x 12 Catalog, booklet, expansion Catalog, booklet, expansion Shop 9 x 12
9 1/2 x 12 1/2 Catalog, booklet Catalog Shop 9 1/2
10 x 13 Catalog, booklet, expansion Catalog, booklet, expansion Shop 10 x 13
10 x 15 Catalog, expansion Expansion (open side) Shop 10 x 15
11 1/2 x 14 1/2 Catalog Catalog Shop 11 1/2
12 x 15 1/2 Catalog Catalog Shop 12 x 15

Herculink® lineup

Flats and expansion only.

  • Catalog: 7 sizes, 6 x 9 to 12 x 15 1/2
  • Booklet: 9 x 12 and 10 x 13
  • Expansion: 1 to 2 in deep, 9 x 12 x 2 to 12 x 16 x 2
  • 100-count cartons on three expansion sizes

Kraft lineup

Small to jumbo.

  • Commercial #6 1/4 to #14
  • Catalog in 9 sizes; booklet in 4
  • Expansion, document, and jumbo up to 24 x 36
  • Tin tie, x-ray, and retention jackets
Booklet or catalog? Booklet envelopes open on the long side; catalog envelopes open on the short side. See catalog vs booklet. For more tough sizes, browse Tyvek envelopes by size.

Strength & Moisture: How Much Protection Do You Need?

When Herculink® makes sense

Worth the extra cost.

  • Heavy packets that strain seams
  • Important or hard-to-replace documents
  • Damp, humid, or rainy routes
  • Long trips with lots of handling
  • Mail that should look premium and arrive flat

When kraft is enough

Strong, simple, and economical.

  • Routine documents and statements
  • Catalogs, reports, and booklets
  • Internal routing and filing
  • High-volume mailings
  • Styles Herculink® doesn’t offer, like #10 or jumbo
Fit matters most: An overstuffed envelope fails no matter the material. Leave about 1/2 inch around the contents, and move to expansion when packets are thick. For the most water resistance, compare Tyvek vs kraft.

Best Uses: Where Each One Shines

Herculink® is best for

Mail that can’t afford to arrive damaged.

  • Legal, financial, and real estate closing packets
  • Contracts, certificates, and original documents
  • Photos, artwork, and graphic proofs
  • Manuals and heavy reports
  • Mail sent through wet or humid weather

Kraft is best for

Everyday mail done right.

  • Office mail, statements, and forms
  • Catalogs, booklets, and brochures
  • Inter-office routing and filing
  • Bulk and direct mail programs
  • Small parts, samples, and x-ray films
Both work for branding: Herculink® and kraft both take printing well. For which material suits each job, see what envelopes are made of.

Printing & Cost: Branding and Value

Printing Herculink®

A paper surface for your brand.

  • Flats: black, 1, 2, 3, or 4 color
  • Expansion: black, 1, or 2 color
  • Logos and labels print cleanly

Printing kraft

Match the ink to the paper.

  • Brown kraft: dark, high-contrast inks
  • White kraft: best for full color
  • Plan it in our free layout tool

Cost

Compare the same size and quantity.

  • Kraft costs less per envelope
  • Herculink® costs more but less than Tyvek®
  • Lower carton prices on larger orders
Real value: The right envelope is the cheapest one that gets your contents there intact. A reprint, a resend, or damaged originals cost far more than a stronger envelope.

How to Choose: Eight Steps

1. Measure the contents

Width, height, and thickness of the full packet.

2. Rate the risk

Heavy, valuable, or headed through bad weather?

3. Pick the material

Herculink® for protection; kraft for everyday.

4. Pick the style

Catalog, booklet, or expansion for thick packets.

5. Pick the closure

Zip Stick® for both; kraft adds gum and reusable seals.

6. Pick the color

Kraft in brown or white; Herculink® in a paper look.

7. Plan printing

Up to 4 color on flats; 2 on Herculink® expansion.

8. Test a sample

Pack, seal, and handle one before the big order.

Want samples? Call 612.867.2121 or email us to compare Herculink® and kraft side by side before you order.

FAQ: Herculink® vs Kraft Envelopes

Quick answers on strength, moisture, sizes, and cost.

What is the difference between Herculink® and kraft envelopes?
Herculink® has a paper outer layer over a 26# reinforced fiber weave and a poly moisture barrier. Kraft is a single strong paper. Herculink® is tougher and more moisture resistant; kraft costs less and comes in more styles.
Is Herculink® stronger than kraft?
Yes. The reinforced weave resists tearing and bursting much better than paper alone, especially with heavy or bulky contents.
Are Herculink® envelopes waterproof?
No. The poly barrier protects against damp handling and humidity, but the envelope shouldn’t be soaked. For the most water resistance, choose Tyvek®.
Are kraft envelopes water resistant?
Not really. Kraft paper handles normal mail well, but it weakens when wet. Choose Herculink® or Tyvek® for damp conditions.
Is Herculink® more expensive than kraft?
Yes, per envelope, but it costs less than a full synthetic like Tyvek®. Compare the same size and carton quantity.
What sizes does Herculink® come in?
Catalog in 7 sizes from 6 x 9 to 12 x 15 1/2, booklet in 9 x 12 and 10 x 13, and expansion from 9 x 12 x 2 to 12 x 16 x 2. Shop Herculink® envelopes.
Does Herculink® come in a #10 size?
No. For a tough #10, choose Tyvek®. For a #10 in kraft, shop kraft commercial envelopes.
How do Herculink® envelopes seal?
Every Herculink® envelope uses Zip Stick® peel & seal. Kraft adds gum, Peerless Tac, tin tie, and string and button options.
Can Herculink® and kraft envelopes be custom printed?
Yes. Herculink® flats print in black to 4 color and expansion up to 2 color. Most kraft styles print in black to 4 color. Learn about custom printing.
Does kraft come in white?
Yes. Most kraft flats come in brown or white. See white vs brown kraft.
Are these envelopes recyclable?
Kraft paper is recyclable. Herculink® has a poly layer, so check with your local recycling program.
Which is best for mailing important documents?
Herculink®, for the added tear, burst, and moisture protection. Shop Herculink® catalog envelopes.

Ready to Order Your Envelopes?

Shop by size, or talk with an envelope specialist who will match the right size, material, and closure to your mailing.

Doug Nelson

About Doug Nelson

Linkedin Profile

Over 40 years of hands-on expertise in the envelope and printing industry. At Easy Envelopes, I partner with businesses to deliver everything from high-volume stock orders to custom-manufactured specialty solutions, including durable Tyvek envelopes. My core focus is taking the guesswork out of mailing logistics. I work closely with the US Postal Service to guarantee that every business reply mail envelope we print meets strict USPS specifications, protecting my clients from costly compliance errors and ensuring they qualify for the absolute lowest postage rates.

© 2026 Easy Envelopes. Buyers Guide Knowledge Base.