Tyvek vs Herculink

Tyvek® vs Herculink® Envelopes

Strength • Moisture • Weight • Cost • Styles • Printing

Tyvek® envelopes and Herculink® envelopes are both built for mail that can’t afford to rip: heavy inserts, long trips, and rough handling. Tyvek® is a full synthetic made from high-density polyethylene fibers. Herculink® puts a reinforced fiber weave and a poly moisture barrier under a paper outer layer, so it looks like paper but resists tearing and bursting.

This guide compares the two side by side, shows every style and size we carry in each, and gives you a quick way to decide. Weighing kraft too? See Tyvek vs Herculink vs kraft.

Ready to order? Start here.

Quick Pick: Tyvek® or Herculink®?

Your Situation Pick Why Shop
Rain, snow, or outdoor drop-offs Tyvek® Most water resistant Shop Tyvek®
Strong envelope with a paper look Herculink® Reinforced weave under paper Shop Herculink
Tough mail on a tighter budget Herculink® Costs less than a full synthetic Shop Herculink
Contents over 2" thick Tyvek® expansion Expands up to 4" Shop Expansion
Watching package postage Tyvek® Lightest tough material Shop Tyvek®
#10 business size Tyvek® commercial Herculink® has no #10 Shop Tyvek® #10
Showing if a packet was opened Tyvek® tamper evident Flap shows “OPENED” Shop Tyvek®
Small run of bulky mail Herculink® expansion 100-count cartons Shop 100 Count
Simple takeaway: Choose Tyvek® for the most water resistance, the lightest weight, and the widest range of styles. Choose Herculink® for a paper look with reinforced strength at a lower cost.

Materials: What Each One Is Made Of

Tyvek®

A full synthetic.

  • Flash-spun high-density polyethylene fibers
  • 14# or 18# weight; very light
  • Water resistant through and through
  • Smooth, bright white (5 colors too)

Herculink®

Three layers in one.

  • Professional paper outer layer
  • 26# reinforced fiber weave
  • Hidden poly moisture barrier
  • Looks and feels like a paper envelope

What they share

Both are built to arrive intact.

  • Resist tearing and bursting
  • Keep contents dry in damp conditions
  • Zip Stick® peel & seal closures
  • Professional printing available
Not waterproof: Herculink® is moisture resistant. Its barrier protects contents from damp and humidity, but it shouldn’t be soaked. For the most water resistance, choose Tyvek®.

Side by Side: How They Compare

Category Tyvek® Herculink® Edge
Tear and puncture Very hard to tear or puncture Reinforced weave resists tears and bursts Both
Moisture Water resistant Moisture barrier; not for soaking Tyvek®
Weight 14# or 18#; very light 26# fiber weave plus paper Tyvek®
Cost Higher per envelope Lower than a full synthetic Herculink®
Look and feel Smooth, fabric-like; white or 5 colors Professional paper look Your brand
Styles Commercial, catalog, booklet, expansion, jumbo, and more Catalog, booklet, expansion Tyvek®
Expansion depth Up to 4" 1" to 2" Tyvek®
Printing Black, 1, 2, 3, or 4 color Flats up to 4 color; expansion up to 2 Both
Recycling #2 HDPE where accepted Ask your local program Tyvek®
Bottom line: Tyvek® wins on water resistance, weight, and choice. Herculink® wins on price and paper look while still resisting tears and bursts. See the Tyvek® envelope buyer’s guide to match sizes and styles.

Styles & Sizes: What We Carry in Each

Style Tyvek® Herculink® Shop
Catalog (open end) 14 sizes, #10 to 12 x 15 1/2 7 sizes, 6 x 9 to 12 x 15 1/2 Shop Herculink
Booklet (open side) 6 sizes, 6 x 9 to 10 x 13 9 x 12 and 10 x 13 Shop Herculink
Expansion (open end) Up to 4" deep 9 x 12 x 2 to 12 x 16 x 2 Shop Herculink
Expansion (open side) Up to 4" deep 10 x 13 x 2, 10 x 15 x 2, 10 x 16 x 2 Shop Tyvek®
Commercial (#10) #10, gum or Zip Stick® Not offered Shop Tyvek®
Jumbo 13 x 19 and 15 x 20 Not offered Shop Jumbo
Tamper evident 9 x 12 and 10 x 13 Not offered Shop Tyvek®
Peerless Tac™ 10 x 13 Not offered Shop Tyvek®
Color 5 colors, 9 x 12 to 12 x 15 1/2 Not offered Shop Color
Cartons: Herculink® catalog and booklet envelopes come 500 per carton; expansion comes 250 per carton, or 100 on three sizes. Browse every size in Tyvek® by size and kraft by size, or see the envelope size chart.

Closures: How Each One Seals

Tyvek® closures

Four ways to seal.

  • Zip Stick® peel & seal on most styles
  • Gum only on #10 commercial
  • Peerless Tac™ resealable (internal use)
  • Tamper evident shows “OPENED”

Herculink® closures

One reliable seal.

  • Zip Stick® peel & seal on every style
  • No moisture needed
  • Fast for hand sealing
  • Holds on heavy, packed envelopes

Which seal?

Match the seal to the job.

  • Hand sealing: Zip Stick® peel & seal
  • Machine inserting: gum on Tyvek® #10
  • Reuse in-house: Peerless Tac™
  • See envelope closures
Security note: Tamper-evident Tyvek® shows “OPENED” if the flap is lifted. It is not tamper proof. Learn more in tamper-evident closures.

Printing: Getting Your Logo On

Printing on Tyvek®

Leave it to us.

  • We print black, 1, 2, 3, or 4 colors
  • Crisp, bright print surface
  • Don’t run it through an office laser printer
  • Heat can melt Tyvek®

Printing on Herculink®

A paper surface for your brand.

  • Flats: black, 1, 2, 3, or 4 color
  • Expansion: black, 1, or 2 color
  • Paper outer layer shows logos well
  • Choose printing when you order

Labels and addressing

Both take labels.

  • Labels stick well to both
  • Keep the address area clear
  • High contrast helps barcodes read
  • See the custom printing guide
Tyvek® printing: We print millions of Tyvek Envelopes and we print them well!

Decide in 30 Seconds: Answer These

Choose Tyvek® if any are true

  • Mail may get wet or sit outside
  • Contents are over 2" thick
  • Package postage is adding up
  • You need #10, jumbo, tamper evident, or color

Choose Herculink® if these are true

  • You want a paper look with extra strength
  • Contents are flat or up to 2" thick
  • Damp, not soaking, conditions
  • Cost matters on a tough envelope
High-volume tip: Test both with your actual contents. Track damage, re-sends, and handling time; small material differences can add up to big savings. Done with a Tyvek® envelope? See how to recycle Tyvek®.
Another material comparison: Guide: Tyvek® vs Kraft
↑ Back to top

FAQ: Tyvek® vs Herculink®

Quick answers on strength, moisture, cost, postage, sizes, closures, and printing.

Which is stronger, Tyvek or Herculink?
Both resist tears and bursts far better than plain paper. Tyvek® is the toughest and most water resistant; Herculink® gets its strength from a 26# reinforced fiber weave under a paper surface.
Which is better in wet weather?
Tyvek®. It is water resistant through the whole sheet. Herculink® has a poly moisture barrier for damp and humid conditions but shouldn’t be soaked.
Is Herculink waterproof?
No. Herculink® is moisture resistant. It protects contents from damp and humidity, not heavy rain or standing water.
Which costs less?
Herculink® costs less than a full synthetic. Tyvek® can still cost less overall when its lighter weight lowers postage or it prevents re-sends.
Which saves postage?
Tyvek® is usually lighter (14# or 18#). Postage depends on the finished piece, so weigh a filled sample of each.
Which is better for heavy or bulky inserts?
For up to 2", either works; Herculink® expansion comes in 8 sizes. For thicker contents, Tyvek® expansion goes up to 4" deep.
What closure do they use?
Herculink® uses Zip Stick® peel & seal on every style. Tyvek® uses Zip Stick® on most styles, plus gum on the #10 commercial, Peerless Tac™, and tamper evident.
Can I get Herculink in a #10 or jumbo size?
No. Herculink® comes in catalog, booklet, and expansion styles. For #10 or jumbo sizes, choose Tyvek® commercial or Tyvek® jumbo.
Can I print on Tyvek myself?
We don’t recommend it. Office laser printers run hot enough to melt Tyvek®. We print millions of Tyvek Envelopes and we print them well!
Can Herculink envelopes be custom printed?
Yes. Flats print in black, 1, 2, 3, or 4 color; expansion in black, 1, or 2 color. See the custom printing guide.
Which looks more professional?
Both do. Herculink® looks like a premium paper envelope; Tyvek® has a smooth, bright, fabric-like finish and comes in 5 colors.
Which is better for sensitive documents?
Both help documents arrive intact. Tamper-evident Tyvek® adds a flap that shows “OPENED” if lifted. No envelope is tamper proof.

Ready to Order Your Envelopes?

Shop by size, or talk with an envelope specialist who will match the right size, material, and closure to your mailing.

Doug Nelson

About Doug Nelson

Linkedin Profile

Over 40 years of hands-on expertise in the envelope and printing industry. At Easy Envelopes, I partner with businesses to deliver everything from high-volume stock orders to custom-manufactured specialty solutions, including durable Tyvek envelopes. My core focus is taking the guesswork out of mailing logistics. I work closely with the US Postal Service to guarantee that every business reply mail envelope we print meets strict USPS specifications, protecting my clients from costly compliance errors and ensuring they qualify for the absolute lowest postage rates.

© 2026 Easy Envelopes. Buyers Guide Knowledge Base.